It’s beginning to feel a bit like 2000

The dotcom crash feels similar to what has happened to artificial intelligence stocks in the past week.
There was an aviation finance conference at The Plaza Hotel in New York on the day the 2000 dotcom crash started. Without Wi-Fi, it was only at lunchtime, when people had time to call their brokers, check their pagers or use a shared computer in the business centre, that the extent of the fall became clear.
The Nasdaq Composite index had peaked at 5,048 on March 10th, 2000, the day before. It finally bottomed out at 1,140 on October 4th, 2002, two years later. While companies like Pets.com, fashion retailer Boo.com and Flooz.com (a digital currency promoted by Whoopi Goldberg) failed, many dotcom companies went on to thrive. This includes an online bookseller which could soon be a leading business jet connectivity provider.
The dotcom crash feels similar to what has happened to artificial intelligence stocks in the past week. (Although the collapse of Enron after accounting issues was nowhere near as exciting as this week’s alleged honeytrap sting).
“Last Thursday’s rout was a correction waiting for a trigger. The Nasdaq 100 fell 6.4%, erasing a record $2.3 trillion,” says Shawn Vick, operating partner at AE Industrial Partners. “The fuel was debt. Hyperscalers have issued an estimated $296bn of bonds this year, about 9% of investment-grade supply. They remain investment grade, but credit markets are repricing them for rising leverage, negative free cash flow and uncertain payback on depreciating assets. As the Democrats won governorships in Texas and Ohio, major centres of data-centre development, investors fear tighter restrictions on the buildout.”
Vick was selling jets at Bombardier after the dotcom correction (he joined from Gulfstream) and there was no panic. OEMs were able to accelerate deliveries for large corporate customers.
According to Global Jet Capital analysis of JetNet data, in 2000 some $19.9bn of new and pre-owned business jet transactions closed (new deliveries accounted for $11.6bn). After the dotcom crash and the September 11th terrorist attacks this fell to $16.4bn in 2003 (new jet deliveries were $8.4bn). It then rose again until 2008.
Textron Aviation illustrates how manufacturer backlogs helped push off the sudden fall in demand. And how hard it is to cut production. It delivered 252 jets in 2001 before shipping what was then a record number of 313 jets in 2002. It cut production to just 196 jets in 2003. In retrospect, it cut too slowly. Cessna booked 525 orders worth $1.7bn in 2002. These sales were helped by the launch of both the Citation Mustang (325 sales) and the new CJ3 (164 orders).
If we see a slowdown now, OEMs have even stronger backlogs to push off a fall in orders. They are also much more balanced companies. Services accounted for almost a third of Bombardier’s recent results, for example.
“At this point I don’t think the risk is cancellations, but we should keep an eye on all the OEMs’ quality of backlog. The very healthy order books are a cushion during a deep V event,” says Vick. “This too shall pass. The questions of course are when and if any significant protracted weakness shows up in the fundamentals of the global economy and how long it will last.” (Vick is one of the speakers on the first panel at CJI Miami next week.)
The pre-owned market followed a similar trend in 2000. The number of pre-owned business jets listed for sale rose from 1,107 (10% of the fleet) in March 2000 to 1,983 (16.13% of the fleet) in October 2002 (up 79%), according to AMSTAT. It also took longer for them to sell. Average days on market went up from 239 to 340. Asking prices (different than transaction prices) barely moved. Sellers were reluctant to cut, leading to adjustments showing up in how long it took to sell rather than price.
The dotcom downturn was relatively short. The National Bureau of Economic Research says it lasted from March 2001 to November 2002. If we are seeing the start of a similar short downturn, it will have little impact. AI companies do not account for that much of the backlog and if they forfeit deposits other customers would be delighted to get earlier deliveries.
Even the best artificial intelligence cannot predict downturns, warn you that a CEO is having multiple affairs or say when you will receive this email after the Microsoft outage. (It has been a bad week for technology). Business aviation is well placed to survive a short V-shaped downturn. Let’s just hope we do not have anything like 2008.
Ed Bolen will be sorely missed
Business aviation has lost one of its biggest champions this week with the sad death of Ed Bolen, former president and CEO of the National Business Aviation Association (NBAA). He died aged 66 following a battle with cancer.
“We are filled with incredible sadness about Ed,” said Dan Hubbard, NBAA acting CEO and senior vice president of communications. “Ed was not just our colleague – he was a friend and a mentor to many of us. He accomplished so much and did so with grace and humility. On behalf of the entire NBAA team, we send our condolences and prayers to Beth, Jack, Robert and all of Ed’s family in this incredibly difficult time.”
Since announcing his retirement on November 6th, NBAA said it received a “tremendous outpouring” of support for Bolen. The same has happened following the announcement of his death.
While he was very much the public face of business aviation, a lot of his work took place behind closed doors. He was great at building consensus. Both President Bill Clinton and President George W Bush picked him for roles.
“In a town full of sharp elbows, Ed’s hallmark was building meaningful relationships and bringing the aviation community together to solve problems,” said Kristie Greco Johnson, senior vice president, Government Affairs at NBAA. “Even in the toughest fights, Ed conducted business with grace, integrity and diplomacy. I’m honoured to have worked with and learned from him.”
As well as a passion for flying, Ed was an accomplished tennis player. By complete coincidence, he was forced to interview a number of players including Martina Navratilova, Andre Agassi and Steffi Graf at various NBAA events over the years.
CJI enjoyed asking Ed about when he would leave NBAA to run for president of the United States of America. He would have made a great one.







